vsEngage AI
Insay vs Engage AI: tones or actions?
Both are Chrome extensions that write LinkedIn comments in the feed. Engage AI lets you set a tone, a length and keywords. Insay asks what the comment should do, like add an insight, push back or ask, then writes it from the post, the other comments and what it knows about you.
Details checked on 16 November 2026. Sources are under the table.
Choose Insay if
- You want comments that make a point, not just sound right
- You comment on X or Reddit, or reply in Gmail, too
- You want facts about you used, and never made up
Choose Engage AI if
- You want fine control over tone, length, emoji and hashtags
- You sell on LinkedIn and want CRM integrations like HubSpot
- You want a community of people commenting on your posts as well
Feature by feature
Insay vs Engage AI, row by row.
| Feature | Insay | Engage AI |
|---|---|---|
| Where it works | LinkedIn, X, Reddit and Gmail | |
| How you steer it | ✓Actions: Add insight, Agree + add, Ask, Counterpoint and more, ranked for the post | ~Tones, plus length, emoji, hashtag and keyword settings |
| Reads other comments | ✓Up to five, so the comment adds something new | ~Reads the post; other comments not described |
| Facts about you | ✓What you shared, never invented beyond it | ~An archive of your past comments, in beta |
| Replies, messages, notes | ✓Replies to comments, messages, connection notes and posts | ~Built around comments |
| Hashtags and emoji | Left out unless you ask | You choose |
| Price | Free plan. Plus $12 a month or $99 a year | Free tier. Pro $30 a month, per its Chrome Web Store listing |
Engage AI details from engage-ai.co and its Chrome Web Store listing on 16 November 2026. Engage AI is a trademark of its owner. Insay isn't affiliated with Engage AI. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at insay@alpstack.com.
To be fair
Where Engage AI is the better pick.
Length, emoji, hashtags and keywords to include or avoid, all set by you.
Connects to HubSpot, Pipedrive and Zapier for social selling.
Its engagement community adds comments from real members to your posts.
Where Insay is different
Where Insay does the job better.
Pick what the comment should do. Insay writes the point, not just the tone.
Up to five other comments, so yours isn't the fourth "Great insight".
LinkedIn, X, Reddit and Gmail.
Questions
Insay vs Engage AI, answered.
Is Insay an Engage AI alternative?
Yes, if you want an extension that writes LinkedIn comments inside the feed. Insay also writes replies, messages, connection notes and posts, and works on X, Reddit and Gmail.
What's the difference between tones and actions?
A tone changes how a comment sounds. An action decides what it does: answer, ask, push back or add an insight. Insay ranks the actions that fit the post, and styles like Professional or Warm are there too, as a second choice.
Does Insay add hashtags or emoji to LinkedIn comments?
No, unless you ask. Insay leaves out hashtags and emoji bullets, and rewrites comments that only praise the post.
Does either one post comments automatically?
Insay never does: you press Comment yourself. Engage AI's drafts don't post on their own either; its community is people commenting by hand.
Is Insay free?
Yes. Insay has a free plan with replies every day on every site it works on. Plus adds more drafts, three drafts to choose from each time and custom voices built from your own writing. See pricing.
More comparisons
How Insay compares.
ChatGPT writes anything you prompt it to. Insay drafts the reply in the box, with no prompt.
CompareInsay vs GrammarlyGrammarly polishes what you typed. Insay reads the thread and drafts the reply.
CompareInsay vs Gemini in GmailGemini is free in Gmail. Insay answers every ask, leaves your decisions to you, and works beyond email.
CompareInsay vs Superhuman MailSuperhuman drafts your email in the background. Insay drafts on demand and works beyond email.
CompareInsay vs MailMaestroMailMaestro drafts Gmail and Outlook replies. Insay answers every ask and works beyond email.
CompareInsay vs TaplioTaplio is a LinkedIn growth suite. Insay does comments and replies, on four sites, for less.
CompareInsay vs SupergrowSupergrow writes and schedules LinkedIn posts. Insay drafts your comments right in LinkedIn.
CompareInsay vs CommentifyCommentify comments for you on autopilot. Insay drafts, and you post.
CompareInsay vs Tweet HunterTweet Hunter is an X growth suite. Insay drafts your X replies on every plan.
CompareInsay vs HypefuryHypefury schedules posts and no longer lists X. Insay drafts your replies on X and more.
CompareInsay vs ReplyGuyReplyGuy finds threads to promote in. Insay helps you reply as yourself.
CompareInsay vs RedimatesBoth draft Reddit replies. Redimates adds Reddit extras; Insay works on four sites.
CompareInsay vs IndraftSame makers, different jobs. Insay writes your replies, Indraft writes your posts.
CompareComment with a point. In your own words.
Coming soon to ChromeFree to start. You review and send every reply.